Sorry Mate, I’m Going to Have to Let You Go…

"Look pal, I'm afraid the drumming's a bit, um... hoofy." "Hmph. I thought you liked cows."

“Look pal, I’m afraid the drumming’s a bit, um… hoofy.” “Hmph. I thought you liked cows.”

At some point we all have to sack a friend and nobody enjoys it.

I’ve seen this situation a lot. I’m afraid those that don’t have the guts to do it tend to wind up with bands that don’t progress. If you’re having trouble working up the courage, just remember that if you don’t bite the bullet, the frustration will mount over time and increasingly undermine the band dynamic. So the friendship is probably going to suffer further down the line anyway – and the more the longer you let it fester.

You have to do it in a totally reasonable and friendly way – highlight and focus on the issue of different interests and styles, suggest they’d probably be happier with another outfit anyway. Perhaps you could suggest that they’ll be first on the list if you have projects in future that are more “them”.

Above all, stress that it’s not personal. We’re all used to “musical differences” being used as a euphemistic code for “can’t stand each other”, but genuine musical differences do exist. Of course, as I said, if you don’t grasp the nettle early on, the blazing rows will usually follow. It really needn’t be personal, but it will often become so if you avoid the issue for long enough.

Rik Mayall played Colin, the bassist in Bad News. He also owned the PA...

Rik Mayall played Colin, the bassist in Bad News. Colin owned the PA…

You should still be prepared for some hurt feelings though – it’s inevitable.

But I’m afraid the fact that “Bill is such a nice guy and we’ve known each other for years” is never a good argument for keeping Bill in the band if he’s not a good match for your music or just not up to it. Owning the PA or van doesn’t really cut it either…

If it’s primarily a recording band, you can use someone who’s erratic, but sometimes great. However, consistency and reliability are more important than genius for live. Obviously, you’d rather have both, but this isn’t an ideal world. In fact, quite a few bands have different recording and touring lineups. This plays to people’s strengths, and reflects the fact that some people are just more interested in or suited to the studio than the road, and vice versa.

No band members were harmed in the writing of this post.

Tagged with: ,
Posted in c) Musicianship, e) Rants & Ramblings
One comment on “Sorry Mate, I’m Going to Have to Let You Go…
  1. anitacov says:

    Thank you Jason for this good article ! Well, music changes through the years and so do the people who make it. It is impossible to say at the beginning of a band that everyone will move on to the same direction. When it comes to say goodbye, everyone should take it as an opportunity for something new, to learn as well and to improve what has not been so good before. Isn’t it what life’s about ?

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Books for Sale
...appetising young books for sale...
Next Gig

We play every month at Toulouse Lautrec in Kennington, South London.

Fri Mar 30th 9pm, £15 (£9 adv)
JLT feat Duncan Eagles ten sax 

For London-wide jazz listings see

%d bloggers like this: